Home/Reviews
Every burger review

Joe’s burger reviews

150 Gold Medal Burgers. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a burger.

150Burgers reviewed
34Cities covered
9.3Top score
Home/Rankings
The Full Leaderboard

Every burger Joe has ranked

150 Gold Medal Burgers across 34 cities, sorted by Joe’s score. Search by name, filter by city, or sort by price to find a great burger near you.

9.3Top score
140Burgers ranked
$12.22Average price
10DQ’s
Rank
Restaurant
City
Price
Joe’s Score
01
oddbirdSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.43
9.3
02
Sasso Pizza Market and BarHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$16.95
9.3
03
Hillfire SMK & BBQFonthill, ON
Fonthill
$11.30
9.2
04
The Black Sheep LoungeWelland, ON
Welland
$12.42
9.2
05
Smoke & Moonshine Authentic BarbequeBeamsville, ON
Beamsville
$20.28
9.1
06
Cat's CabooseSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
9.0
07
Parker's Pub & EateryPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$7.00
8.9
08
Cool Hand Luke's Bar and GrillNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$10.17
8.9
09
WahlburgersToronto, ON
Toronto
$12.38
8.9
10
Fonthill Food CompanyFonthill, ON
Fonthill
$14.68
8.9
11
Butcher and BankerFonthill, ON
Fonthill
$16.94
8.9
12
Waldhaus Pub & BiergartenBanff, AB
Banff
$29.40
8.9
13
Julia's Bistro and CateringDunnville, ON
Dunnville
$13.23
8.8
14
Silversmith Brewing CompanyVirgil, ON
Virgil
$16.10
8.8
15
Coop BurlingtonBurlington, ON
Burlington
$13.54
8.7
16
Karma Kameleon GastropubThorold, ON
Thorold
$14.69
8.7
17
The Urban Steakhouse & LoungeFonthill, ON
Fonthill
$15.81
8.7
18
The Huron ClubCollingwood, ON
Collingwood
$21.47
8.7
19
The Merchant Ale HouseSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.94
8.6
20
SaltlikBanff, AB
Banff
$19.95
8.6
21
Mister ChipsWelland, ON
Welland
$6.00
8.5
22
Grand Central Sports BarNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$6.78
8.5
23
Cheers RestaurantWelland, ON
Welland
$10.11
8.5
24
Buried Treasure CaféNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$11.30
8.5
25
Debb's Cuisine On QueenDunnville, ON
Dunnville
$13.56
8.5
26
The Broken GavelFenwick, ON
Fenwick
$13.57
8.5
27
Abe's DinerAirdrie, AB
Airdrie
$14.70
8.5
28
The Spot Bar & GrillPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$9.61
8.4
29
Trappers Sports BarWelland, ON
Welland
$9.61
8.4
30
DJ's RoadhouseWainfleet, ON
Wainfleet
$10.00
8.4
31
Whisky Run Golf ClubPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$13.00
8.4
32
The TrapFonthill, ON
Fonthill
$13.56
8.4
33
Kame & Kettle Beer WorksFonthill, ON
Fonthill
$14.95
8.4
34
Burlington Charcoal PitBurlington, ON
Burlington
$5.53
8.3
35
Avondale Food StoresWainfleet, ON
Wainfleet
$6.77
8.3
36
Pinks BurgersHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$7.05
8.3
37
M&J's Family RestaurantFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$4.53
8.2
38
The Rex HotelWelland, ON
Welland
$7.00
8.2
39
The Big SizzleNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$7.06
8.2
40
The Eager BeaverNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$10.17
8.2
41
La Bohème CuraçaoWillemstad, Curaçao
Willemstad
$13.30
8.2
42
Breakwall Brewing CompanyPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$13.56
8.2
43
Ye Olde SquireWelland, ON
Welland
$13.56
8.2
44
Mick & Angelo's Kitchen + BarNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$15.00
8.2
45
Taps BrewhouseNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$15.82
8.2
46
Garrisons GrillNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$6.50
8.1
47
The Burger's PriestHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$6.77
8.1
48
Small DimensionsDunnville, ON
Dunnville
$6.89
8.1
49
For Pizza's SakeWelland, ON
Welland
$9.04
8.1
50
Manhattans Bar and GrillSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.55
8.1
51
Niko's PlaceNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$5.00
7.9
52
The Hungry PutterWainfleet, ON
Wainfleet
$7.75
7.9
53
Brewins PubNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$12.15
7.9
54
Jordan House Tavern & LodgingJordan Station, ON
Jordan Station
$13.56
7.9
55
Curbside GrillHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$14.95
7.9
56
1st RNDEdmonton, AB
Edmonton
$23.00
7.9
57
Archie's Subs and EateryPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$6.16
7.8
58
Fat Louie's American Style PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$13.55
7.8
59
Beacon HarboursideJordan Station, ON
Jordan Station
$15.82
7.8
60
Dawg's Burgers & FriesPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$6.50
7.7
61
Queens Merritt RoomDunnville, ON
Dunnville
$7.91
7.7
62
Touchdown Willy's Tap & GrillSmithville, ON
Smithville
$11.30
7.7
63
LAMA RestaurantRidgeway, ON
Ridgeway
$16.95
7.7
64
State & Main Kitchen & BarHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$18.65
7.7
65
Boogie'sCalgary, AB
Calgary
$6.83
7.6
66
The WORKS Gourmet Burger BistroNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$14.55
7.6
67
MJ's Own MunchiesSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$5.11
7.5
68
Tailgates Bar and GrillWelland, ON
Welland
$9.03
7.5
69
Doc Magilligan's Restaurant & Irish PubNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$18.08
7.5
70
Bricks & BarleyNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$13.56
7.4
71
The VHC (The Vegan Hippie Chick)Welland, ON
Welland
$15.82
7.4
72
Grumpy Gramma'sWelland, ON
Welland
$7.35
7.3
73
Wendel Clark's Classic Grill & BarBurlington, ON
Burlington
$11.24
7.3
74
Jasper Pizza PlaceJasper, AB
Jasper
$12.79
7.3
75
The Blind Pig NiagaraNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$13.50
7.3
76
Kaytoo Restaurant and BarBlue Mountains, ON
Blue Mountains
$22.04
7.3
77
On the Twenty RestaurantJordan Station, ON
Jordan Station
$22.60
7.3
78
2 x 4 DinerWainfleet, ON
Wainfleet
$8.98
7.2
79
Fat Cats PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$10.68
7.2
80
South Coast CookhouseCrystal Beach, ON
Crystal Beach
$14.69
7.2
81
Strada WestNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$16.95
7.2
82
Wendy'sPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$5.97
7.1
83
Delirious Burger CoHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$6.09
7.1
84
Burger Cafe & BeyondSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$6.65
7.1
85
U Need a PitaWelland, ON
Welland
$6.90
7.1
86
Bada Bing RoadhouseWelland, ON
Welland
$8.46
7.1
87
Eddie Burger BarBanff, AB
Banff
$19.43
7.1
88
The Garrison HouseNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$21.48
7.1
89
Country Chip WagonDunnville, ON
Dunnville
$7.76
6.9
90
Rickijo's RestaurantSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.42
6.9
91
Walter's & Neptunes RestaurantPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$6.72
6.8
92
The Real McCoyNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$8.46
6.8
93
Grill on CanboroFenwick, ON
Fenwick
$8.98
6.8
94
Jeffro's BBQNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$9.04
6.8
95
Bob's PlaceDunnville, ON
Dunnville
$10.16
6.8
96
Chop House Burger BarSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$11.29
6.8
97
My Place Bar & GrillFonthill, ON
Fonthill
$14.11
6.8
98
Wainfleet Motel & RestaurantWainfleet, ON
Wainfleet
$9.59
6.7
99
Memphis Fire Barbecue CompanyStoney Creek, ON
Stoney Creek
$13.56
6.7
100
The Burnt TongueHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$7.31
6.6
101
Fairmont Château Lake LouiseLake Louise, AB
Lake Louise
$26.25
6.6
102
Chuck BurgerBlue Mountains, ON
Blue Mountains
$12.40
6.4
103
Rolly's SmokehouseSmithville, ON
Smithville
$11.29
6.3
104
The Garden HouzzPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$15.25
6.3
105
The Rib Crib and SmokeshopSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.08
6.3
106
Olympia Bar and RestaurantWelland, ON
Welland
$7.35
6.2
107
Iggy's Pub & GrubFonthill, ON
Fonthill
$17.25
6.2
108
The Feathery PubSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$17.52
6.2
109
McDonald'sFonthill, ON
Fonthill
$7.33
6.1
110
Champ BurgerShelburne, ON
Shelburne
$8.76
6.1
111
The Canalside RestaurantPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$11.02
6.1
112
The KavernWelland, ON
Welland
$11.29
6.1
113
Fresco's Euro GrilleSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$15.81
6.1
114
SuperburgerShelburne, ON
Shelburne
$7.62
5.9
115
Dock Bar & KitchenWillemstad, Curaçao
Willemstad
$12.36
5.9
116
Crystal Chandelier CafeCrystal Beach, ON
Crystal Beach
$12.37
5.9
117
HAMBRGRSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.43
5.9
118
PL8 OF FRIESWelland, ON
Welland
$6.50
5.8
119
Burger BarnOhsweken, ON
Ohsweken
$10.99
5.8
120
Belmont HotelPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$10.74
5.7
121
Fionn MacCool'sHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$17.52
5.7
122
Kaz's PubSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.94
5.6
123
Lost Penny PubWestport, ON
Westport
$13.56
5.4
124
Peter Piper's PubhouseFonthill, ON
Fonthill
$15.00
5.4
125
The Upper Deck TapHouse + GrillSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$15.81
5.4
126
Flying Saucer RestaurantNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$6.75
5.3
127
Five GuysStoney Creek, ON
Stoney Creek
$5.03
5.2
128
Papa's GrillWelland, ON
Welland
$6.78
5.2
129
The Reeb HousePort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$12.42
5.2
130
Peters' Drive-InCalgary, AB
Calgary
$5.09
5.1
131
Boo's Bar & EateryVineland, ON
Vineland
$8.58
4.9
132
Moe's Tap & WingsPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$10.17
4.7
133
Handlebar HanksWelland, ON
Welland
$10.34
4.6
134
Bugsy'sSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.38
4.2
135
The George HamiltonHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$16.95
4.1
136
Blue Star RestaurantWelland, ON
Welland
$5.00
3.9
137
Smithville PizzeriaSmithville, ON
Smithville
$5.64
3.9
138
Fiddlers Pour HouseSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.69
3.6
139
Rise AboveSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$19.21
3.6
140
Boon Burger CaféHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$11.02
2.7
DQ
335 On The RidgeRidgeway, ON
Ridgeway
$19.21
DQ
DQ
BRGRZ IncCollingwood, ON
Collingwood
$10.00
DQ
DQ
Brux House Craft Beer & KitchenHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$21.47
DQ
DQ
Fireside RestaurantWelland, ON
Welland
$6.78
DQ
DQ
Hutch's on the BeachHamilton, ON
Hamilton
$4.80
DQ
DQ
Mr. Mikes SteakhouseCasualWelland, ON
Welland
$13.55
DQ
DQ
Outback SteakhouseNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$22.59
DQ
DQ
Restaurant & Café Gouverneur De RouvilleWillemstad, Curaçao
Willemstad
$19.56
DQ
DQ
The Cove Country InnWestport, ON
Westport
$11.87
DQ
DQ
Trailside Bar and GrillRidgeway, ON
Ridgeway
$14.68
DQ
No burgers match that search. Try another city or name.
How the list works

One judge. One burger.

Every restaurant on this list was visited by Joe and scored on camera, and every one got the same order: a Gold Medal Burger with lettuce, onion and pickle only. The same person scores every burger, so an 8.5 in Welland means the same thing as an 8.5 in Banff.

Prices are what Joe paid on the day of his visit, so they’re a guide, not a menu. A DQ means the restaurant couldn’t serve the burger as ordered.

Craving pizza?

Joe has reviewed over a thousand pizzerias. Find the best slice near you.

Visit review.pizza