Home/Reviews
Every burger review

Joe’s burger reviews

150 Gold Medal Burgers. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a burger.

150Burgers reviewed
34Cities covered
9.3Top score
Cat's Caboose burger review

Cat's Caboose Burger Review – St. Catharines, ON

December 20, 2019•3 min read
← All Burger Reviews
Gold Medal Burger Quest · #6 of 140

Cat's Caboose Burger Review – St. Catharines, ON

JGBy Joe GonzalezDecember 20, 2019 · Burger Reviews
Joe's Score9.0 / 10
Price$14.68
LocationSt. Catharines, ON
Leaderboard#6 of 140

Cat's Caboose on Glenridge Avenue in St. Catharines calls itself Canada's original road house, and it's huge inside, seating around 265 people according to the owner. Chef Chris follows me on Instagram and had been chirping at me to come by. I finally did, and the burger earned a 9.0, good for #6 out of 140 on my Gold Medal Burger rankings.

My order, plus a surprise

I ordered the Gold Medal Burger, a hamburger with lettuce, onion and pickle only, for $14.68. When the bag came over it was suspiciously heavy. Inside, along with the burger, was a meal for Robyn and a $25 Cat's Caboose gift card. Listen, the burger man can't be bribed, so I turned it into a pay it forward: that gift card goes to someone who engages with the video.

First look

The chef told me the patty is made from meat ground fresh in house every day. I think he said brisket, but my goldfish memory might be failing me. They weren't shy on toppings either, with plenty of pickles, red onions and romaine. Chris also mentioned he knows Justin from oddbird, the current leader on the quest, so that name drop had some weight to it.

First bite

One bite, everybody knows the rules, and gifts aside, this is a legit burger. Juicy and dripping. My only worry is the one every reviewer has when the kitchen knows who you are. I really hope this is the burger everybody gets.

The breakdown

  • Bun: A great bun that held everything together.
  • Patty: Ground in house daily, juicy and generous. At least four ounces, and likely more.
  • Toppings: Romaine lettuce, red onion and a lot of sweet pickles.
  • Value: $14.68 for a burger this size and quality is fair.

Robyn eats for once

Robyn, who usually just holds the camera, finally got a meal of her own: what looked like a chicken salad with bean sprouts and a dipping sauce. I tried to talk her into doing a review of it.

My verdict

I couldn't think of how to make this burger any better, and Robyn guessed my score before I said it: 9.0. That puts Cat's Caboose in the elite territory of the quest. The score has nothing to do with the gift card. I did give them a 10 for generosity, though. Maybe you don't have to leave St. Catharines to find the best burger in the world.

Find Cat's Caboose

224 Glenridge Ave, St. Catharines, ON

View on GoogleGet Directions

JG
About the author

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez spent years on a quest for the world’s best Gold Medal Burger, ordering the same burger at 150 restaurants across Niagara and beyond and scoring every one on camera. He also reviews pizza on review.pizza.

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez is a REALTOR® and the broker of record at Right Choice Happenings Realty in Wainfleet, Ontario. He's also the face behind the pizza and burger reviews, host of the Happenings Podcast, and the guy who went from 251.8 lbs to 174.8 on camera with Health Happenings.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog