Home/Reviews
Every burger review

Joe’s burger reviews

150 Gold Medal Burgers. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a burger.

150Burgers reviewed
34Cities covered
9.3Top score
The Black Sheep Lounge burger review

The Black Sheep Lounge Burger Review – Welland, ON

September 20, 2019•3 min read
← All Burger Reviews
Gold Medal Burger Quest · #4 of 140

The Black Sheep Lounge Burger Review – Welland, ON

JGBy Joe GonzalezSeptember 20, 2019 · Burger Reviews
Joe's Score9.2 / 10
Price$12.42
LocationWelland, ON
Leaderboard#4 of 140

After a month away from burgers while I launched a new real estate brokerage, I restarted the Gold Medal Burger quest at one of my favourite restaurants anywhere: The Black Sheep Lounge on Niagara Street in Welland. It was worth the wait. The Black Sheep scores a 9.2, good for #4 out of 140 burgers.

Reviewing a friend

I've been to The Black Sheep many times, including for Must See Mondays, and I'm good friends with the owner, Lucas. The burger is a newer addition to the menu, and Lucas had been asking when I'd come try it. I told him what I tell everybody: I come when I come. I always get a little nervous reviewing friends, but I knew Lucas would take any criticism or props in stride.

My order

Robyn placed the order for a hamburger with lettuce, onion and pickle only, and I went in to pay. It was $12.42 and came with plenty of napkins. Lucas told me something no other stop ever had: the packaging is compostable. It was snug, branded and kept the burger tight. I could smell it before I even opened the box.

First bite after a month off

One bite, everybody knows the rules, and the juices were flowing. You could taste the crunch of the toasted bun, and the patty was big and dripping with flavour. This is a happening happenings burger.

What's in it

  • Bun: Toasted, maybe with butter, and baked at the bakery right next door.
  • Patty: Thick, homemade and juicy. I'm guessing around seven ounces or more.
  • Pickles: Homemade and horizontally sliced, not spears. A little sour, but not too sour.
  • Onions and lettuce: Red onions I'm pretty sure were caramelized, plus chopped lettuce.
  • Value: $12.42 for this much meat is a strong deal.

My one critique

If I had to nitpick, it was the meat to bun ratio. The patty was so big it ran a little heavy for the bun. But too much meat is a good problem to have, and my preference for a smaller patty is personal. Even so, I could eat two of these.

My verdict

I knew The Black Sheep was quality, but I didn't know if the burger would reach the nines. It did, with a 9.2. Juicy, cooked right, homemade from the pickles to the patty, and served on a fresh local bun, it was the perfect way to come back from a hiatus. If you're in Welland, this one is a must.

Find The Black Sheep Lounge

Welland, ON

View on GoogleGet Directions

JG
About the author

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez spent years on a quest for the world’s best Gold Medal Burger, ordering the same burger at 150 restaurants across Niagara and beyond and scoring every one on camera. He also reviews pizza on review.pizza.

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez is a REALTOR® and the broker of record at Right Choice Happenings Realty in Wainfleet, Ontario. He's also the face behind the pizza and burger reviews, host of the Happenings Podcast, and the guy who went from 251.8 lbs to 174.8 on camera with Health Happenings.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog