Home/Reviews
Every burger review

Joe’s burger reviews

150 Gold Medal Burgers. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a burger.

150Burgers reviewed
34Cities covered
9.3Top score
oddbird burger review

oddbird Burger Review – St. Catharines, ON

May 13, 2019•3 min read
← All Burger Reviews
Gold Medal Burger Quest · #1 of 140

oddbird Burger Review – St. Catharines, ON

JGBy Joe GonzalezMay 13, 2019 · Burger Reviews
Joe's Score9.3 / 10
Price$12.43
LocationSt. Catharines, ON
Leaderboard#1 of 140

Everybody in Niagara had been talking about oddbird, the new spot at the corner of St. Paul and William Street in downtown St. Catharines, so I came to find out if the burgers lived up to the buzz. They did. oddbird scores a 9.3 and sits at #1 out of 140 burgers on my Gold Medal Burger rankings, and now it's the bar every other stop on the quest has to clear.

A good sign before I even opened the bag: I spotted people who run their own restaurants eating inside.

My order

Same as always: a hamburger with lettuce, onion and pickle only. The staff knew exactly what was going on. They asked if it was the Gold Medal Burger and confirmed no cheese. The price was $12.43, a little above average, but I was betting the value would be there. It came in a brown paper bag stamped with the oddbird name, and I liked that branding right away.

First bite on St. Paul Street

The burger was hot, smelled great and was dripping before I even lifted it. One bite, everybody knows the rules, and the juice was running onto the sidewalk. Whoever is seasoning these patties knows what they're doing. It's not just salt. There's pepper in there and a lot more going on, and the flavours shine. It even brought back memories of a classic burger I love, only better. I'll say it: there's a new sheriff in town.

Bun, patty and toppings

  • Bun: A toasted brioche bun, and I'm guessing they add butter when they toast it.
  • Patty: Homemade "all day long," cooked perfectly and juicy like you wouldn't believe.
  • Toppings: Horizontally sliced pickles and thinly sliced onions, with the lettuce soaking up the juice.
  • Ratio: The bun to burger ratio is perfect.
  • Value: $12.43, and worth every cent for a burger at this level.

A guest bite

Local mortgage agent Brandon Currie happened to walk by, so I handed him a bite for the quest's first guest appearance. Brandon went with a 9. Good score, but a rookie one, missing a decimal point. I agreed it belonged in the nines, and I thought it was even better than that.

My verdict

This is the kind of stop that makes the quest worth it. Perfectly cooked, juicy, seasoned like a champion and sitting on a buttery toasted brioche bun, oddbird earns a 9.3, the best burger of the quest. I have no idea how this gets beaten. If you feel like a hamburger in St. Catharines, stop the car, map it and go to oddbird.

Find oddbird

St. Catharines, ON

View on GoogleGet Directions

JG
About the author

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez spent years on a quest for the world’s best Gold Medal Burger, ordering the same burger at 150 restaurants across Niagara and beyond and scoring every one on camera. He also reviews pizza on review.pizza.

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez is a REALTOR® and the broker of record at Right Choice Happenings Realty in Wainfleet, Ontario. He's also the face behind the pizza and burger reviews, host of the Happenings Podcast, and the guy who went from 251.8 lbs to 174.8 on camera with Health Happenings.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog