Home/Reviews
Every burger review

Joe’s burger reviews

150 Gold Medal Burgers. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a burger.

150Burgers reviewed
34Cities covered
9.3Top score
Cool Hand Luke's Bar and Grill burger review

Cool Hand Luke's Bar and Grill Burger Review – Niagara Falls, ON

April 09, 2020•3 min read
← All Burger Reviews
Gold Medal Burger Quest · #8 of 140

Cool Hand Luke's Bar and Grill Burger Review – Niagara Falls, ON

JGBy Joe GonzalezApril 9, 2020 · Burger Reviews
Joe's Score8.9 / 10
Price$10.17
LocationNiagara Falls, ON
Leaderboard#8 of 140

Cool Hand Luke's Bar and Grill sits in a small plaza on Drummond Road in Niagara Falls, the kind of place tourists drive right past. I'd never been, and after one bite I figured that's the locals' gain. Cool Hand Luke's scores an 8.9, good for #8 out of 140 burgers on my Gold Medal Burger rankings, and it's one of the best deals on my list.

My order

A hamburger with lettuce, onion and pickle only, for $10.17. While I waited, I chatted with a regular at the bar who drives in from Ridgeway because of the nice people and good prices. When I asked him about the burger, he kept it simple: it's a good burger.

It came in a plastic bag inside a medium styrofoam container, wrapped up to keep it warm, with pickle spears on the side.

First bite

As soon as I unwrapped it, the juices started running. I tried to keep them going into the bun, then went in from the back of the burger. One bite, everybody knows the rules. The first thing I tasted was the juice, then fresh ground pepper, before I even hit the toppings. It's kind of like a gravy burger. It would be hard to eat only half, and it's worth the extra burpees.

Breaking it down

  • Bun: Toasted with a little butter. The bottom bun soaked up all the juice, and I saved it for my last bite.
  • Patty: A hundred percent homemade and super juicy, seasoned with pepper. I spotted what looked like parsley and maybe mustard seed in the mix.
  • Toppings: Lots of red onion and romaine lettuce. The pickles came as spears, and that's the only thing wrong here. Slice them up, Luke's. The pickle itself was good, not the best, not the worst.
  • Value: About ten bucks for a burger at this level is a steal.

My verdict

Juicy, peppery and cheap, Cool Hand Luke's lands just under the nines with an 8.9. I believe it's the best burger I've had in Niagara Falls. It might be off the tourist trail, but if visitors knew about it, they'd be lined up with the locals. If I lived in Niagara Falls, this would be my watering hole.

Find Cool Hand Luke's Bar and Grill

Niagara Falls, ON

View on GoogleGet Directions

JG
About the author

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez spent years on a quest for the world’s best Gold Medal Burger, ordering the same burger at 150 restaurants across Niagara and beyond and scoring every one on camera. He also reviews pizza on review.pizza.

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez is a REALTOR® and the broker of record at Right Choice Happenings Realty in Wainfleet, Ontario. He's also the face behind the pizza and burger reviews, host of the Happenings Podcast, and the guy who went from 251.8 lbs to 174.8 on camera with Health Happenings.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog