Home/Reviews
Every burger review

Joe’s burger reviews

150 Gold Medal Burgers. Every one ordered, paid for and scored on camera. Watch the video, read the write-up, then go get a burger.

150Burgers reviewed
34Cities covered
9.3Top score
Papa's Grill burger review

Papa's Grill Burger Review – Welland, ON

December 04, 2020•3 min read
← All Burger Reviews
Gold Medal Burger Quest · #128 of 140

Papa's Grill Burger Review – Welland, ON

JGBy Joe GonzalezDecember 4, 2020 · Burger Reviews
Joe's Score5.2 / 10
Price$6.78
LocationWelland, ON
Leaderboard#128 of 140

After time out west and up north, Robyn and I brought the Gold Medal Burger quest home to Niagara with a stop at Papa's Grill on East Main Street in Welland. The people were lovely, the price was low and the patty was big, but the burger scored a 5.2, placing it #128 out of 140 on my Gold Medal Burger rankings.

A friendly welcome

Papa's Grill serves breakfast, Italian food and Venezuelan dishes, and the prices looked good across the board. Staff came out to say hello while I was filming, and I got to meet the owner too. I asked what I should order next time, the answer was a Latino combo, and I'm coming back for that Venezuelan food. It's that kind of place.

My order

A hamburger with lettuce, onion and pickle only, for $6.78. That makes it one of the cheapest burgers on the quest. It arrived with a toothpick cut right through the middle.

What's on it

A sesame seed bun, chopped iceberg lettuce, red onion and horizontally sliced ruffled pickles that looked like sweet pickles. The patty was big, at least six ounces by my estimate, and it had the look of a backyard burger, the kind of frozen pre-made patty you'd grill at home. It smelled good. One bite, everybody knows the rules.

First bite

There's a lot going on. It's juicy, which is a plus. I've talked before about a ceiling for backyard burgers, and this one got off to a good start. Sweet pickles aren't my favourite, but I liked the chopped lettuce and the raw red onion. The bun was the weak link. Papa's is just up the street from a well-known local bakery, and I joked they should be getting their buns there. Even one of the folks inside admitted it's not the best bun.

  • Bun: Sesame seed, and not my favourite.
  • Patty: Big and juicy, backyard style.
  • Toppings: Chopped iceberg and red onion were good, sweet pickles less so.
  • Value: A lot of burger for $6.78.

My verdict

I've got to be honest at all times, and the owner could tell from my face that this wasn't the best burger on the quest. Nice people, a cheap burger and plenty of it, but a backyard patty, sweet pickles and an average bun add up to a 5.2. Papa's Grill isn't calling itself a burger place anyway. I'm excited to come back for the Venezuelan food, and that's probably the move for anyone visiting.

Find Papa's Grill

Welland, ON

View on GoogleGet Directions

JG
About the author

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez spent years on a quest for the world’s best Gold Medal Burger, ordering the same burger at 150 restaurants across Niagara and beyond and scoring every one on camera. He also reviews pizza on review.pizza.

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez

Joe Gonzalez is a REALTOR® and the broker of record at Right Choice Happenings Realty in Wainfleet, Ontario. He's also the face behind the pizza and burger reviews, host of the Happenings Podcast, and the guy who went from 251.8 lbs to 174.8 on camera with Health Happenings.

LinkedIn logo icon
Instagram logo icon
Youtube logo icon
Back to Blog